Avoiding Home Warranty Scams: What You Need to Know

Important: While most home warranty companies are legitimate businesses, some bad actors exist. Learn how to protect yourself from scams and choose reputable providers.

Common Home Warranty Scams

🚫 Robocall Scams

Unsolicited calls claiming your warranty is expiring or offering limited-time deals. Legitimate companies don't cold-call aggressively.

🚫 Fake Renewal Notices

Official-looking letters claiming you must renew immediately. Always verify with your actual provider.

🚫 Upfront Payment Scams

Requests for large upfront payments or wire transfers. Legitimate companies offer standard payment methods.

🚫 Coverage Denial Schemes

Companies that collect premiums but deny all claims using technicalities not disclosed upfront.

Red Flags to Watch For

  • ❌ High-pressure sales tactics with "today only" offers
  • ❌ Requests for payment via wire transfer or gift cards
  • ❌ No physical address or only a P.O. box
  • ❌ No clear contract or terms of service
  • ❌ Extremely low prices that seem too good to be true
  • ❌ No licensing information or state registrations
  • ❌ Poor or no online presence/reviews
  • ❌ Refusal to provide written documentation before payment
  • ❌ Claims of government affiliation or endorsement
  • ❌ Aggressive telemarketing or door-to-door sales

How to Verify Legitimate Companies

1. Check State Licensing

Verify the company is licensed in your state. Many states require home warranty companies to register.

2. Research Online Reviews

Check multiple sources: BBB, Trustpilot, ConsumerAffairs. Look for patterns in complaints.

3. Read the Contract

Legitimate companies provide clear contracts before purchase. Read all terms carefully.

4. Verify Contact Information

Call the company directly using numbers from their official website, not from unsolicited contacts.

5. Check Financial Stability

Look for companies with strong financial backing and years in business.

Legitimate vs. Scam: Key Differences

✅ Legitimate Companies

  • Clear, detailed contracts
  • State licensing displayed
  • Established online presence
  • Multiple payment options
  • Transparent pricing
  • Real customer service
  • Physical business address
  • No aggressive sales tactics

❌ Potential Scams

  • Vague or no contracts
  • No licensing information
  • Limited online presence
  • Wire transfers only
  • Hidden fees everywhere
  • Impossible to reach
  • P.O. box only
  • High-pressure tactics

What to Do If You've Been Scammed

  1. Contact Your Bank: If you've made payments, contact your bank immediately to stop further charges.
  2. File a Complaint: Report to your state's Attorney General and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
  3. Document Everything: Keep all emails, contracts, and communication records.
  4. Report to BBB: File a complaint with the Better Business Bureau.
  5. Warn Others: Leave reviews on consumer sites to help others avoid the scam.
  6. Consider Legal Action: For significant losses, consult with a consumer protection attorney.

Trusted Home Warranty Companies

To help you choose safely, we've reviewed established companies with proven track records:

Liberty Home Guard (LHG)

In business: 8 years | BBB: NR

Read Full Review →

American Home Shield (AHS)

In business: 54 years | BBB: B

Read Full Review →

Old Republic Home Protection (ORHP)

In business: 51 years | BBB: A+

Read Full Review →

Choice Home Warranty

In business: 16 years | BBB: B

Read Full Review →

First American Home Warranty

In business: 41 years | BBB: B+

Read Full Review →